Can an NCO appeal their NCOER?

An NCO can indeed appeal their Noncommissioned Officer Evaluation Report (NCOER) if they believe there were inaccuracies or unjust evaluations reflected in the report. The core of this process underscores the importance of fairness and accountability in performance evaluations. To substantiate an appeal, the NCO must provide substantial evidence that supports their claims regarding incorrect ratings. This evidence can include, but is not limited to, documentation of accomplishments, witness statements, or other relevant records that illustrate discrepancies between the NCO’s performance and the ratings they received.

The requirement for substantial evidence ensures that the appeal process is grounded in factual information and not merely based on perception. It protects both the integrity of the evaluation process and the rights of the NCO, allowing them a structured means to contest evaluations that they genuinely believe are inaccurate. Therefore, the emphasis on substantial evidence is crucial to maintain the credibility and effectiveness of the military’s evaluation system.